FCA Principles of Business: what all 12 mean for an insurance broker

The FCA Principles for Businesses are 12 rules in PRIN 2.1 that bind every authorised firm. What each asks of a UK broker, and how the FCA enforces them.

By FCB.ai, ORIS editorial teamEditorial lead: The ORIS editorial teamPublished on Updated on 9 min read
Contents
  1. Who sets the Principles and who must follow them
  2. 11 or 12 Principles? Why many guides are out of date
  3. The twelve Principles at a glance
  4. Principles 1 to 5: how the firm is run
  5. Principles 6 to 9: dealing with clients
  6. Principles 10 to 12: money, the regulator and outcomes
  7. Principles for Businesses, Conduct Rules and detailed rules
  8. What happens when a firm breaches a Principle
  9. A self-check by Principle
  10. Frequently asked questions

The FCA "principles of business", officially the Principles for Businesses, are twelve high-level rules in PRIN 2.1 of the FCA Handbook that every authorised firm must follow: integrity, skill and care, management and control, financial prudence, market conduct, customers' interests, communications, conflicts of interest, relationships of trust, clients' assets, relations with regulators and, since 31 July 2023, the Consumer Duty. They are binding rules, not guidance: the FCA can fine a firm for breaching a Principle even when no detailed rule in ICOBS, SYSC or CASS has been broken.

This guide explains where the Principles come from, why guides listing eleven are out of date, what each one means on a broker's desk, and what happens when a firm breaches one.

Who sets the Principles and who must follow them

The FCA makes rules under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA) and publishes them in its Handbook. PRIN, the Principles for Businesses sourcebook, sits in the "High Level Standards" block, alongside SYSC (systems and controls), COND (threshold conditions) and COCON (individual conduct). The detailed sourcebooks a broker uses every day, ICOBS for selling and servicing insurance, CASS 5 for client money, DISP for complaints, are the practical expression of the Principles.

PRIN 3 sets the scope. The Principles apply to every authorised firm, including small brokerages and the appointed representatives they are responsible for, in relation to regulated activities and the activities connected with them. Some Principles reach further: Principles 3, 4 and, for disclosure to the regulator, 11 also apply in a prudential context to a firm's unregulated activities. Some Principles apply differently depending on the client, which is why the split between retail customers and commercial clients matters to a broker (see Principles 6, 7 and 12 below).

Because they are short and general, the Principles are "principles-based regulation" in the sense studied by Julia Black in the Capital Markets Law Journal: they state an outcome and leave the firm to work out, and evidence, how it meets it.

11 or 12 Principles? Why many guides are out of date

For years there were eleven Principles. The FCA's policy statement PS22/9 added Principle 12, the Consumer Duty, which came into force on 31 July 2023 for products and services open to sale or renewal, and on 31 July 2024 for closed products and services. Any list that stops at Principle 11 predates the Duty.

Principle 12 also changed two older Principles: where the Consumer Duty applies, Principles 6 (customers' interests) and 7 (communications) no longer apply. Under Principle 12, PRIN 2A adds three cross-cutting obligations (act in good faith, avoid causing foreseeable harm, enable and support retail customers to pursue their financial objectives) and four outcomes (products and services, price and value, consumer understanding, consumer support).

The twelve Principles at a glance

PrincipleIn shortWhere a broker usually meets it
1. IntegrityConduct business with integrityHonest dealing with clients and insurers, fair presentation of the risk
2. Skill, care and diligenceDo the job competentlyMarket checks at renewal, accurate policy documents, follow-through on claims
3. Management and controlOrganise and control the firm responsibly, with adequate risk managementRecord-keeping, oversight of advisers and appointed representatives, introducers, outsourcing
4. Financial prudenceKeep adequate financial resourcesCapital resources and professional indemnity cover under MIPRU
5. Market conductObserve proper standards of market conductMostly wholesale and London Market activity
6. Customers' interestsPay due regard to customers' interests and treat them fairlyBusiness outside the Consumer Duty, such as many commercial clients
7. CommunicationsClear, fair and not misleadingBusiness outside the Consumer Duty
8. Conflicts of interestManage conflicts fairlyCommission, insurer-paid incentives, panels and binding authorities
9. Relationships of trustSuitability of advice for customers who rely on your judgmentAdvised sales and recommendations
10. Clients' assetsAdequate protection for clients' assets you are responsible forClient money under CASS 5
11. Relations with regulatorsBe open and cooperative, tell the FCA what it would expect to knowNotifications, breaches, changes in control
12. Consumer DutyAct to deliver good outcomes for retail customersAll retail business: products, value, understanding, support

Principles 1 to 5: how the firm is run

Principles 1 and 2 are the ones most often cited when an individual file goes wrong: a client told cover was in place when it was not, a material fact left out of a presentation, a renewal sent without checking the market. They are evidenced by what a good file contains anyway: what the client said, what was checked, what was sent and when.

Principle 3 is where most systemic findings land: a firm must take reasonable care to organise and control its affairs responsibly and effectively, with adequate risk management systems. For a brokerage it covers who signs off a new insurer or scheme, how advisers are supervised, how introducers are vetted, and whether client conversations are kept somewhere the firm controls. Advice given on an adviser's personal phone is a Principle 3 problem before it is a record-keeping problem; see our guide to archiving WhatsApp under SYSC 9.

Principle 4 is met by an insurance intermediary mainly through MIPRU, which sets capital resources and professional indemnity requirements. Principle 5 rarely touches a retail broker directly.

Principles 6 to 9: dealing with clients

For a broker with a mixed book, the Consumer Duty creates a split:

  • Retail customers within the Duty's scope: Principle 12 and PRIN 2A.
  • Customers outside the Duty, which can include many commercial clients depending on the Handbook definitions: Principles 6 and 7 still apply.

Either way, a message to a client must be accurate, balanced and understandable for the person receiving it. A renewal message that leads with a lower price and hides a new exclusion fails both tests.

Principle 8 covers conflicts between the firm and its customers and between customers: commission, volume-based incentives from insurers and delegated authority are the usual sources for a broker. Principle 9 applies where a customer relies on the firm's judgment: the advice must be suitable. In general insurance it works alongside the demands and needs rules in ICOBS 5, covered in our guide to demands and needs when you sell over WhatsApp.

Principles 10 to 12: money, the regulator and outcomes

Principle 10 is about clients' assets; for brokers that means client money under CASS 5: where premiums and claims money are held, under which trust or risk transfer arrangement, and how they are reconciled. Principle 11 requires an open and cooperative relationship with the FCA. In a small firm the failure is rarely concealment; it is not realising that something was notifiable, such as a significant breach or a problem at an appointed representative.

Principle 12 requires a firm to act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers. Our guide to the four Consumer Duty outcomes and the evidence on each client file works through them for a brokerage.

Principles for Businesses, Conduct Rules and detailed rules

The Principles bind the firm. Individuals are bound by the Conduct Rules in COCON 2.1, introduced for brokers by the Senior Managers and Certification Regime: six individual rules that mirror several Principles (integrity, due skill, care and diligence, openness with regulators, treating customers fairly, market conduct and, since the Duty, acting to deliver good outcomes for retail customers). Our guide to SM&CR for insurance brokers covers the individual side.

PrincipleMain detailed rules for a broker
2, 6, 7, 9, 12ICOBS (disclosure, demands and needs, product information, renewals, claims), PRIN 2A
3SYSC (systems and controls, record-keeping, competent staff)
4MIPRU (capital resources, professional indemnity)
8SYSC conflicts rules, ICOBS remuneration disclosure
10CASS 5 (client money of insurance intermediaries)
11SUP 15 (notifications)

Competence links Principles 2 and 3 to people: SYSC 5.1.1R requires a firm to employ personnel with the skills, knowledge and expertise needed for their responsibilities, and staff in insurance distribution must complete at least 15 hours of professional training a year (FCA PS17/21). Record that training, including on the Principles, and link it to supervision; our guide on becoming an insurance broker in the UK covers qualifications, and our guide to the Chartered Insurance Broker title explains the CII's higher CPD bar for Chartered brokers.

What happens when a firm breaches a Principle

The FCA can impose a financial penalty under section 206 FSMA or publish a statement of censure under section 205, and it sets penalties with the five-step framework in DEPP 6.5A. Two broker cases show that a Principle alone is enough:

  • Aon Limited (Final Notice, 6 January 2009, issued by the FSA): a £5.25 million penalty for breaching Principle 3 through weak controls over payments to overseas third parties, after a 30% early settlement discount (£7.5 million before discount).
  • JLT Specialty Limited (Final Notice, 19 December 2013): a £1,876,000 penalty for breaching Principle 3 in its anti-bribery and corruption controls over overseas introducers, also after a 30% discount (£2,684,013 before discount). The notice records no evidence of any illicit payment: the failing was the controls.

Neither case cites a detailed rule as the main breach. That is the practical lesson for a small brokerage: weak oversight is sanctionable in itself.

A self-check by Principle

  1. Integrity, skill (1, 2): could you show, from the file, what a client was told at renewal and why?
  2. Control (3): are all client conversations, including WhatsApp, on channels the firm controls and can supervise?
  3. Prudence (4): is the PI cover and capital calculation current?
  4. Clients (6 to 9, 12): do you know which clients are inside the Consumer Duty, and is your commission disclosure accurate?
  5. Client money (10): are reconciliations done and reviewed on time?
  6. Regulator (11): does someone own the list of notifiable events?

The channel clients actually use is often the quickest win. When conversations run through a firm number and a shared inbox, such as the one ORIS provides on the WhatsApp Business Platform, what was said sits on the client record rather than on a personal phone, which helps with Principles 3, 7 and 12 at once. The United Kingdom broker page summarises the wider UK framework.

Frequently asked questions

How many FCA Principles for Businesses are there: 11 or 12?

Twelve. Principle 12, the Consumer Duty, was added by PS22/9 with effect from 31 July 2023. Lists of eleven Principles predate the Duty.

Are the FCA Principles for Businesses legally binding?

Yes. They are rules made under FSMA, and the FCA can take enforcement action for a breach of a Principle alone, as the Aon and JLT final notices for breaches of Principle 3 show.

Does Principle 12 replace Principles 6 and 7?

Only where the Consumer Duty applies. Principles 6 and 7 continue to apply to business outside its scope, which for a broker can include commercial clients, depending on the Handbook definitions.

What is the difference between the Principles for Businesses and the Conduct Rules?

The Principles in PRIN apply to the firm. The Conduct Rules in COCON apply to individuals working in it under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime, with extra rules for senior managers.

Do the Principles apply to a broker's commercial clients?

Yes. The Principles cover the firm's regulated business whatever the client, with some adjustments set out in PRIN 3. For clients outside the Consumer Duty, Principles 6 and 7 apply instead of Principle 12.

Where are the Principles in the FCA Handbook?

In PRIN 2.1, with the detailed Consumer Duty rules under Principle 12 in PRIN 2A and the scope of application in PRIN 3.

See ORIS in action

Shared WhatsApp inbox, client records, follow-ups and opportunities for the whole brokerage. 15-minute demo.

Book a demo

Free kit : WhatsApp template pack for insurance brokers

This guide and its companions as a printable PDF, with a sourced checklist up front. 15 pages · PDF · 601 KB.

See the kit
Book a demo