FCA Consumer Duty for insurance brokers: the four outcomes and how to evidence each one on the client file

What the FCA Consumer Duty asks of insurance brokers: the cross-cutting rules, the four outcomes, what each client file must show and what the FCA checks.

By FCB.ai, ORIS editorial teamEditorial lead: The ORIS editorial teamPublished on 9 min read
Contents
  1. What the Duty is, in one page
  2. The four outcomes, and what each client file should show
  3. What the FCA actually looks at
  4. A file review a small brokerage can run each quarter
  5. Common gaps on broker files
  6. Where a WhatsApp layer helps, and where it does not
  7. Frequently asked questions

The FCA Consumer Duty is Principle 12 of the FCA's Principles for Businesses: "A firm must act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers." For an insurance broker it means three cross-cutting rules (act in good faith, avoid causing foreseeable harm, enable and support customers to pursue their financial objectives) and four outcomes to deliver and prove: products and services, price and value, consumer understanding and consumer support. The rules have applied since 31 July 2023 for products open to sale and since 31 July 2024 for closed books, as set out in the FCA's policy statement PS22/9.

Most summaries stop at the list. The harder question for a brokerage of a few people is practical: when a supervisor, an auditor or the Financial Ombudsman opens one client's file, what should be in it to show the Duty was applied to that person? This guide works outcome by outcome from the rule to the file.

What the Duty is, in one page

The Duty sits in PRIN 2A of the FCA Handbook. It applies to retail market business, including prospective customers, and it follows the distribution chain: a firm that can determine or materially influence outcomes is accountable even when the customer is not its direct client. The obligations are read in proportion to the firm's role, so a broker is not judged as if it had designed the policy, but it is judged on what it chose to recommend, how it explained it and how it looked after the client afterwards.

The three cross-cutting rules in PRIN 2A.2 are the test every file is read against:

  • Good faith: honest, fair and open dealing, consistent with what the client could reasonably expect.
  • Avoiding foreseeable harm: across design, sale and ongoing service, not just at the point of sale.
  • Enabling and supporting: giving clients what they need to act in their own interests, including removing barriers and accounting for vulnerability.

Two points specific to insurance change how brokers apply the first two outcomes. The products and services rules in PRIN 2A.3 and the price and value rules in PRIN 2A.4 are disapplied for non-investment insurance, because the product governance and fair value rules in PROD 4 already cover that ground. The outcome still has to be delivered; the evidence simply follows PROD 4.

The four outcomes, and what each client file should show

OutcomeWhere the rule sits for a brokerWhat one client file should showThe question a reviewer asks
Products and servicesPROD 4 (distributor duties), read with PRIN 2AThe client falls in the insurer's target market; demands and needs recorded; why this cover and not anotherWas this product meant for someone like this client?
Price and valuePROD 4 fair value rulesPremium, fees and commission disclosed; what the market exercise was; add-ons and premium finance explainedDoes the total cost, including your remuneration, make sense for what the client gets?
Consumer understandingPRIN 2A.5The key messages actually sent, when, and the client's replies; exclusions and excess flagged before the decisionCould this client make a properly informed decision from what you sent?
Consumer supportPRIN 2A.6Requests, claims and cancellation asks with the time taken to deal with them; vulnerability noted and acted onWas it as easy to get help, claim or leave as it was to buy?

If your firm also reports on these outcomes to its board, the guide to a small brokerage's board report covers the aggregated view. The file-level evidence below is what that report should be built from.

1. Products and services: the target market and the reason for the recommendation

For a broker, the products outcome is about distribution: obtaining enough information from the insurer on who a product is for, and making sure it reaches that group. On the individual file, that looks like a demands and needs statement that reflects the conversation, a note of anything that put the client at the edge of the target market (a sole trader on a policy built for larger firms, a young driver on a scheme with heavy restrictions), and the reason the recommended cover was preferred.

The common weakness is a file that shows a product was sold but not why it fitted. If the reasoning happened in a phone call or a WhatsApp exchange on someone's personal phone, the file cannot show it.

2. Price and value: remuneration and the renewal decision

Fair value for insurance runs through PROD 4, and a distributor must not let its own remuneration undermine the value of the product. On the file, the evidence is concrete: what the client paid in premium, fees and commission, what was disclosed and when, and at renewal what market exercise was done and why the client stayed or moved. Premium finance and optional add-ons deserve their own line, because they change the total cost. Our guide on PROD 4 fair value and commission evidence goes into the firm-level assessment.

3. Consumer understanding: what was sent, and whether it landed

PRIN 2A.5 asks that communications meet customers' information needs, are likely to be understood and equip them to make effective, timely and properly informed decisions, and that firms test and monitor communications where appropriate. The file-level question is simple: can you show what the client was told before each decision, and is there any sign they did not understand it?

Messaging channels help here, because the record is the conversation itself. A renewal prompt that names the change in cover in plain words, and the client's reply, is stronger evidence than a PDF attached to an email nobody opened. Two realistic examples:

Hi {first_name}, your home policy renews on {renewal_date}. One change this year: the insurer now applies a separate excess for escape of water. The full renewal pack is here: {link}. If anything is unclear, reply here and {adviser} will call you.

Hi {first_name}, before you decide on the add-on for legal expenses: it is optional, it costs {price} a year on top of your premium, and it does not change your main cover. Would you like it included, yes or no?

A repeated question from the same client ("so am I covered if…?") is also evidence, of the opposite kind. It tells you a communication failed, and the Duty expects you to notice and adapt.

4. Consumer support: requests, claims, cancellations and vulnerability

PRIN 2A.6 requires support that meets customers' needs, including those with characteristics of vulnerability, and no unreasonable barriers when a customer wants to make an enquiry, change or switch a product, claim, complain or cancel. The Handbook's own example of a likely breach is waiting times that are disproportionately longer to cancel or change a product than to buy one.

On the file, that means a visible trail: when the client asked, when the firm answered, what happened next. It also means a note when a client disclosed something relevant (bereavement, illness, money trouble) and what the firm did differently as a result. Our process for vulnerable customers on WhatsApp shows how to record that without over-collecting health data.

Hi {first_name}, thanks for letting us know. We have paused any renewal reminders for now. When you are ready, reply here or tell us a better time to talk, and {adviser} will take it from there.

Hi {first_name}, we have received your cancellation request for {policy}. We will confirm the refund position with the insurer and come back to you on this number. You do not need to send anything else.

What the FCA actually looks at

The FCA's insurance multi-firm review of outcomes monitoring covered 20 larger firms, including insurance intermediaries. Its findings are the clearest public signal of what supervisors test, and they apply equally to smaller firms, which the FCA expects to take a proportionate approach with simpler governance:

  • Outcomes, not process completion. Poor practice was relying on the fact that a review was done rather than on what customers experienced.
  • Groups of customers. Most firms did little to compare outcomes for customers with characteristics of vulnerability against other customers.
  • Claims. The review found little monitoring of whether claim settlements delivered good outcomes overall.
  • The distribution chain. Good practice included insights from other parties in the chain and analysis of commission and costs across it.

The FCA's published Consumer Duty focus areas add current insurance priorities, including the consumer understanding outcome in home and travel insurance and the premium finance market study. For a personal-lines broker, those are the files to check first.

A file review a small brokerage can run each quarter

  1. Pick a small sample by client group: new business, renewals, claims, cancellations, and anyone flagged as vulnerable. Averages across the whole book hide exactly the differences the FCA asks about.
  2. Read each file against the table above. For each outcome, mark whether the evidence is on the file, somewhere else, or nowhere.
  3. Read the conversation, not just the documents. Look for repeated questions, unanswered messages and requests that took several chasers.
  4. Record the finding and the fix: a template rewritten, a step removed from the cancellation route, an adviser coached. The action is the evidence that monitoring works.
  5. Feed the result upwards into your management information and the annual assessment.

Common gaps on broker files

  • Client conversations on advisers' personal phones, so the reasoning and the explanations never reach the file.
  • Renewal communications sent, but no record of what changed or whether the client read it.
  • Vulnerability noticed by one adviser and invisible to the colleague who picks up the next message.
  • Cancellation requests answered with a retention call before the request is acknowledged.
  • Commission and fees disclosed at inception and never revisited at renewal.

Where a WhatsApp layer helps, and where it does not

No tool delivers good outcomes on its own; the Duty is about decisions. What a shared channel changes is the evidence. In ORIS, client conversations run through a business number and a shared inbox rather than personal phones, and sit against the client in Customers & Segments. Campaigns go out only from Meta-approved templates to clients with a WhatsApp opt-in, opt-outs are honoured automatically, and response and engagement data can be exported as CSV for your own monitoring. AI drafts replies for an adviser to check, and automatic replies only run under rules the firm sets, with negative-sentiment messages always held for a person. If you want to see how that record looks for a renewal or a claim, book a demo.

Frequently asked questions

What is the FCA Consumer Duty in simple terms?

It is Principle 12 of the FCA's Principles for Businesses, requiring firms to act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers. It is backed by three cross-cutting rules and four outcomes: products and services, price and value, consumer understanding and consumer support, with detailed rules in PRIN 2A.

Does the Consumer Duty apply to small insurance brokers?

Yes, where the firm does retail market business. There is no size exemption, but the FCA expects a proportionate approach, and obligations are read according to the firm's role in the distribution chain and its ability to influence outcomes.

How do the price and value rules work for general insurance?

The PRIN 2A.4 price and value rules do not apply to non-investment insurance products. Brokers meet the price and value outcome through the PROD 4 fair value rules instead, including checking that their own remuneration does not undermine fair value.

Can WhatsApp conversations count as Consumer Duty evidence?

Yes, if they are kept by the firm and attached to the client record. A conversation showing what the client was told, what they asked and how quickly they were helped is direct evidence for the understanding and support outcomes. Messages on an adviser's personal phone generally are not.

Does the Duty apply to commercial clients?

The Duty applies to retail customers as defined in the FCA Handbook for each activity. Whether a given commercial client is in scope depends on that definition, so check it for your book with your compliance adviser rather than assuming either way.

See ORIS in action

Shared WhatsApp inbox, client records, follow-ups and opportunities for the whole brokerage. 15-minute demo.

Book a demo

Free kit : WhatsApp template pack for insurance brokers

This guide and its companions as a printable PDF, with a sourced checklist up front. 15 pages · PDF · 601 KB.

See the kit
Book a demo