SM&CR for insurance brokers: senior managers, certification and the Conduct Rules

How SM&CR applies to a UK brokerage: Limited Scope, Core or Enhanced, senior manager roles, yearly certification and the six Conduct Rules.

By FCB.ai, ORIS editorial teamEditorial lead: The ORIS editorial teamPublished on 4 min read
Contents
  1. Which category is your brokerage?
  2. The Senior Managers Regime
  3. The Certification Regime
  4. The Conduct Rules
  5. Where it shows up in daily broking
  6. Frequently asked questions

The Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) applies to every FCA solo-regulated insurance broker. It has three parts: the Senior Managers Regime, which makes named individuals accountable for parts of the business; the Certification Regime, under which the firm itself assesses certain staff as fit and proper every year; and the Conduct Rules, which apply to almost everyone working in the firm. How much of it applies depends on whether your firm is Limited Scope, Core or Enhanced.

The regime reached solo-regulated firms, including brokers, in December 2019. The FCA notes that it is undergoing reform as part of the government's wider financial services agenda, so check the FCA's SM&CR pages for the current position before changing your own arrangements.

Which category is your brokerage?

CategoryWho falls in itWhat it means
Limited ScopeSole traders, and some other firm types that meet the conditions in SYSC 23 Annex 1Fewer senior management functions and some baseline requirements disapplied
CoreMost authorised brokeragesThe baseline requirements
EnhancedFirms over one of the FCA's thresholds, including total intermediary regulated business revenue of £45 million or more a year (3-year rolling average) and CASS large firmsAdditional requirements, such as responsibilities maps and overall responsibility

Firms decide their own category from the rules, and can choose to opt up to a higher category by notifying the FCA. A firm cannot pick and choose: opting up means taking on all the requirements of that category.

The Senior Managers Regime

Senior managers need FCA approval before they start, and each has a statement of responsibilities. In a Core brokerage the usual senior management functions are:

  • SMF1 Chief Executive and SMF3 Executive Director for those running the firm;
  • SMF9 Chair where the firm has a board chair;
  • SMF16 Compliance Oversight, the person responsible for compliance;
  • SMF17 Money Laundering Reporting Officer, where the firm is subject to the money laundering regulations;
  • SMF27 Partner in a partnership.

Limited Scope firms typically have fewer roles, often a single Limited Scope Function (SMF29). Prescribed responsibilities, such as responsibility for compliance with the SM&CR itself, are allocated to senior managers so that someone is clearly accountable. In a small brokerage the same person often holds several functions; what matters is that the statement of responsibilities matches what they actually do.

The Certification Regime

Some staff who are not senior managers can still cause significant harm to clients or the firm. Under the Certification Regime the firm, not the FCA, must assess them as fit and proper before they start and at least once a year, and issue a certificate. For a brokerage this commonly includes staff performing client-dealing roles where certification functions apply, and those who supervise them. The assessment looks at honesty, competence and financial soundness, and the firm must obtain regulatory references when hiring into these roles. How brokers build that competence in the first place, through supervision, CII qualifications and yearly CPD, is covered in our guide to insurance broker training in the UK.

Certified staff and some other individuals also appear on the FCA's public Directory, which clients and other firms can search.

The Conduct Rules

The Conduct Rules in the FCA's COCON sourcebook apply to almost all staff, not only senior managers. There are six individual Conduct Rules:

  1. Act with integrity.
  2. Act with due skill, care and diligence.
  3. Be open and cooperative with the FCA, the PRA and other regulators.
  4. Pay due regard to the interests of customers and treat them fairly.
  5. Observe proper standards of market conduct.
  6. Act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers.

Rule 6 came with the Consumer Duty; where it applies, Rule 4 does not. Senior managers also follow additional senior manager conduct rules on controlling the business, compliance, delegation and disclosure to the regulator. Firms must train staff on the rules that apply to them and notify the FCA of breaches that lead to disciplinary action.

Where it shows up in daily broking

For an account handler, the Conduct Rules are concrete: a message that tells a client they are covered without checking, a complaint left unlogged, a renewal pushed without explaining a change in cover. For senior managers, the question is whether they can show they took reasonable steps: that supervision, records and controls existed and were used.

Records of client conversations are a large part of that evidence. When advisers talk to clients on their personal phones, a senior manager cannot show what was said or supervise it. ORIS gives brokerages a shared WhatsApp inbox on the firm's number, with each conversation attached to the client record and visible to supervisors, which supports the reasonable steps a senior manager needs to evidence. Our guide to archiving WhatsApp under SYSC 9 covers the record-keeping side, and the FCA Principles for Businesses sit above all of it.

Frequently asked questions

Does SM&CR apply to insurance brokers?

Yes. Since December 2019 it has applied to FCA solo-regulated firms, which include insurance brokers. The firm's category, Limited Scope, Core or Enhanced, determines how much of the regime applies.

How many individual Conduct Rules are there?

Six. The sixth, acting to deliver good outcomes for retail customers, was added with the Consumer Duty; where it applies, the fourth rule on treating customers fairly does not.

Is a sole trader broker Limited Scope?

Yes. The FCA states that sole traders are Limited Scope firms under the SM&CR.

Who certifies staff under the Certification Regime?

The firm does. It must assess certified staff as fit and proper before they start and at least once a year, and issue a certificate.

Is the SM&CR changing?

The FCA states that the regime is undergoing reform as part of the government's financial services agenda. Check the FCA's SM&CR pages for the current rules before changing your arrangements.

See ORIS in action

Shared WhatsApp inbox, client records, follow-ups and opportunities for the whole brokerage. 15-minute demo.

Book a demo

Free kit : WhatsApp template pack for insurance brokers

This guide and its companions as a printable PDF, with a sourced checklist up front. 15 pages · PDF · 601 KB.

See the kit
Book a demo