FCA change in control: buying or selling a UK insurance brokerage

When buying into a UK insurance broker needs FCA approval: the 20% threshold, section 178 notices, the 60 working day assessment and what to prepare.

By FCB.ai, ORIS editorial teamEditorial lead: The ORIS editorial teamPublished on 5 min read
Contents
  1. The rule: approval before completion
  2. The threshold for an insurance broker: 20%
  3. Situations that catch brokers out
  4. What the FCA assesses
  5. Timetable
  6. After completion
  7. Frequently asked questions

Consolidation is a fact of life in UK broking: principals retire, groups buy regional firms, and management teams buy out founders. Whenever someone acquires shares or voting power in an FCA-authorised brokerage, the change in control regime in Part XII of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA) applies. Get it wrong and the consequence is not a delay but a criminal offence. This guide sets out when approval is needed for a general insurance intermediary, what the FCA assesses and how long it takes.

The rule: approval before completion

Section 178 of FSMA requires a person who decides to acquire or increase control over a UK authorised person to notify the regulator first. The FCA describes these as section 178 notices. Approval must be obtained before the change takes place, and section 191F makes it a criminal offence to acquire or increase control without it. The FCA also states that a person who decides to acquire control is caught wherever they live: being based outside the UK does not take the deal out of the regime.

For a firm regulated only by the FCA, which is the position of almost every insurance broker, the notification goes through the FCA's Connect system.

The threshold for an insurance broker: 20%

The FCA distinguishes Directive firms (banks, insurers, MiFID investment firms and others), which have several control bands, from non-Directive firms. General insurance intermediaries are non-Directive firms, and for them there is only one controller band: 20% or more. Under the FSMA (Controllers) (Exemption) Order 2009, a notification is required when a person decides to acquire:

  • 20% or more of the shares or voting power of the brokerage;
  • 20% or more of the shares or voting power of its parent undertaking; or
  • shares or voting power that would allow the person to exercise significant influence over the brokerage, even below 20%.

Holdings are aggregated. Shares held by people acting in concert, such as family members, count together, and the FCA treats parent undertakings of minority shareholders as controllers. Shares without voting rights are still caught, because the definition refers to shares or voting power.

Situations that catch brokers out

SituationApproval needed?
A new holding company is inserted above the brokerage, ultimate owner unchangedYes: the holding company is a new controller
A founder transfers shares to a spouse or childrenLikely, if the holdings acting in concert reach the threshold
An approved 20%+ controller of a non-Directive firm increases its stakeNo prior approval for the increase, but check whether others cease to be controllers or become new ones
A controller reduces its stake or exitsNo approval, but the FCA must be told beforehand
Buying an appointed representative firmNot under this regime: AR firms are exempt, though the principal firm must oversee the change
Acquiring a sole trader's businessSole traders are exempt from the regime; the buyer still needs its own authorisation to carry on the business

Buying a book of clients from another firm, without buying its shares, is not an acquisition of control of that firm. It raises other questions, such as client communication, data protection and whether the buyer's own permissions cover the business, but not a section 178 notice.

What the FCA assesses

The FCA states that, when preparing a notification, the acquirer must explain how the firm will continue to meet each threshold condition. It also expects:

  1. A notification form for every proposed controller, individual or corporate, including each intermediate holding company.
  2. Ownership charts showing close links and any regulated entities in the group.
  3. Evidence of funding and its source.
  4. Criminal background checks for individual controllers and beneficial owners, obtained no earlier than six months before the notification (a DBS check in England and Wales, or an equivalent elsewhere).
  5. A business plan where the acquirer will hold more than 50%. Until the FCA receives an adequate plan, the notification stays incomplete. The plan should cover the business to be undertaken with projected financials, governance, staff and key roles, outsourcing, systems and controls, and how the firm will meet the Consumer Duty.

The FCA also looks at whether the proposed controller made a decision to acquire: its awareness of the transaction, its ability to influence or block it, changes in governance and the source of funding.

Timetable

The FCA first confirms whether the notification is complete. From that point it has up to 60 working days to assess it. If it asks for more information in writing, it can interrupt that period for up to 30 business days. If it objects, it issues a warning notice within the statutory period and the acquirer can make representations. In practice, the long-stop date in the sale agreement should allow for the completeness check, the full assessment period and a possible interruption.

After completion

  • Update the firm's controller details and, if roles change, the senior manager approvals under SM&CR.
  • Report controllers in the annual controllers report on RegData.
  • Check that professional indemnity cover, capital and client money arrangements still fit the enlarged group.
  • Tell clients what changes for them, in plain language, and make sure their questions reach someone who can answer.

That last step is where client retention is won or lost. ORIS gives a brokerage one WhatsApp number on the official Meta platform and a shared inbox where every conversation is attached to the client record, so an acquiring team can see the history of each client relationship instead of inheriting it on departing staff members' phones. Customer data is imported by CSV, and campaigns use Meta-approved templates sent only to clients who opted in.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage triggers a change in control for an insurance broker?

For general insurance intermediaries, which are non-Directive firms, there is a single threshold of 20% or more of the shares or voting power of the firm or its parent, or a holding that gives significant influence.

How long does FCA change in control approval take?

The FCA has up to 60 working days from the date the notification is complete, excluding any interruption of up to 30 business days if it requests more information.

What happens if control is acquired without approval?

Acquiring or increasing control without approval is a criminal offence under section 191F of FSMA. The FCA asks anyone in that position to notify it as soon as possible after the event.

Do I need approval to buy a client book from another broker?

Not under the change in control regime, because you are not acquiring shares or voting power in the selling firm. Your own permissions must cover the business, and the transfer must respect data protection and client communication rules.

Is a business plan always required?

The FCA requires one when an individual or company will acquire more than 50% control. It can be useful in smaller deals too, because it answers the questions the FCA will ask about resources and governance.

See ORIS in action

Shared WhatsApp inbox, client records, follow-ups and opportunities for the whole brokerage. 15-minute demo.

Book a demo

Free kit : WhatsApp template pack for insurance brokers

This guide and its companions as a printable PDF, with a sourced checklist up front. 15 pages · PDF · 601 KB.

See the kit
Book a demo