Your appointed representative advises on WhatsApp: what a principal firm has to see

Principals answer for what their ARs say to clients. SUP 12 duties, the FCA’s 2024 findings, and how to supervise advice given in WhatsApp threads.

By FCB.ai, ORIS editorial teamEditorial lead: The ORIS editorial teamPublished on 7 min read
Contents
  1. What SUP 12 puts on the principal
  2. Where principals were falling short
  3. The WhatsApp question: whose number, whose thread
  4. An oversight pack you can actually run
  5. Frequently asked questions

If your firm is a principal, everything your appointed representative says to a client is, in regulatory terms, something your firm said. Section 39 of the Financial Services and Markets Act makes the principal responsible for the AR's regulated activities as if they were its own, and the FCA supervises you on that basis. That was manageable when an AR's client contact happened by phone, email and on the AR's own letterhead. It is a different problem when the advice is given in a WhatsApp thread on an adviser's phone that your firm has never seen.

This is a practical guide for general insurance principals: what SUP 12 actually requires, where the FCA found principals falling short, and how to build oversight of chat-based client contact that survives an annual review and a complaint.

What SUP 12 puts on the principal

The rules tightened on 8 December 2022 with the changes confirmed in PS22/11. The obligations a principal in general insurance carries today include:

  1. A written agreement with each AR that defines the scope of the regulated activities it may carry on, and which you keep up to date as that scope changes.
  2. Advance notification. Tell the FCA at least 30 days before an AR appointment takes effect, and at least 10 calendar days before changes to the regulated activities an existing AR carries on.
  3. An annual review of each AR, at least every 12 months, covering the fitness and propriety and competence of the AR's senior management, the AR's financial position, and the adequacy of your own controls and resources to oversee it. Keep a written record of each review. The 15-hour annual CPD minimum also reaches AR staff, as explained in our guide to insurance broker training and CPD.
  4. An annual self-assessment: a single document identifying risks and gaps in your compliance with your obligations as a principal, reviewed and signed off by your governing body at least every 12 months, kept for at least six years and produced to the FCA on request.
  5. Annual data on complaints and revenue for each AR, submitted through the regular reporting channel within 60 business days of your annual reporting date.

None of that mentions WhatsApp, and that is precisely the trap. The rules are written in terms of outcomes — do you understand what the AR is doing, can you evidence it, can you intervene — and a channel your firm cannot see defeats all three.

Where principals were falling short

In September 2024 the FCA published its findings on how principals were embedding the new rules. Of the firms it assessed in depth, 83% had completed their self-assessments, but only 52% of those were of good quality; 82% had completed their annual reviews, with only 43% of good quality. Around one in five firms had not done the required checks at all.

The finding that matters most for client communications is quieter. Roughly two thirds of firms said they used data and management information to monitor AR activity and about half made firm-facing visits — but fewer than a third said they checked consumer-facing materials. Marketing pages, quote documents and, increasingly, the messages an adviser actually sends a client are where scope breaches and unfair outcomes show up first. A principal who reviews the AR's balance sheet annually and never reads a client conversation has a review that looks complete and evidences almost nothing about conduct.

The WhatsApp question: whose number, whose thread

Before you can monitor chat you have to settle who controls it. Four decisions belong in the AR agreement, not in a conversation at termination:

  • Who owns the number and the WhatsApp Business Account. Whoever holds the WABA holds the message history and the ability to move the number. If the AR owns it, your access ends when the relationship does — along with the records you may need for a complaint two years later.
  • Whether personal phones are allowed at all. An adviser using a personal WhatsApp account gives no visibility, no retrieval and no handover. If you permit it as a transitional step, put an end date on it.
  • Which trading name appears. The display name a client sees should be consistent with what is on the FS Register and with your disclosure requirements; our guide to the WhatsApp display name for brokers covers how Meta approves it.
  • Controller and processor roles. If AR client data sits in an inbox your firm operates, write down who is controller for what under UK GDPR, and how a subject access request or an erasure request is handled between you.

Then there is what happens inside the thread. Promotions sent to a list of clients are financial promotions and need approval on the same basis as any other communication — see WhatsApp broadcasts and the FCA financial promotion rules. Expressions of dissatisfaction typed into chat are complaints for DISP purposes whether or not anyone forwards them. And the record-keeping expectations that apply to your files apply to the messages too, as set out in our guide to archiving WhatsApp under SYSC 9 and ICOBS.

An oversight pack you can actually run

The FCA's own examples of good practice are unglamorous and repeatable: reviewing consumer-facing material, file checks against the scope of the AR agreement, monthly comparison of the AR's reported activity against the principal's own data, and quarterly checks that feed the annual review rather than a scramble in the final week. Translated into a chat-based brokerage, that looks like this.

EvidenceFrequencyWhat it answers
Sample of client conversations per AR, read and annotatedQuarterlyIs the AR staying inside scope, and are outcomes fair?
List of message templates the AR can send, with approval statusOn changeFinancial promotions and consistency of disclosure
Named users with inbox access, joiners and leaversMonthlyWho spoke to clients in your firm's name
Complaints identified in chat and logged in the registerContinuousDISP timescales and the annual complaints data
Opt-in and opt-out records for marketing messagesContinuousPECR and UK GDPR exposure
MI: message volumes, reply times, unanswered conversations by ARMonthlyConsumer support outcome under the Consumer Duty
Extract of the above filed with the annual review paperAnnuallyThe audit trail the FCA asks for

A single shared inbox for the network makes each of those a query rather than a request. In ORIS, conversations sit under the client record with named users and audit logs, campaigns can only be built from templates that Meta has approved, opt-outs are honoured across queued messages, and customer and campaign data exports to CSV for the review file. It gives a principal something specific to put in the self-assessment: not "we oversee our ARs' communications", but the sample size, the dates, the findings and what changed afterwards.

Two cautions. Access to an AR's client conversations is not a licence to trawl them; define the sampling basis, tell the ARs it happens, and record why. And do not treat the inbox as the whole of your oversight — the FCA's concern in 2024 was firms doing one thing well and calling it a framework.

Frequently asked questions

Does a principal have to read every message an AR sends?

No. The expectation is proportionate monitoring: a defined sample, chosen on a risk basis, with the findings recorded and followed up. What you do need is the ability to retrieve any conversation on request — for a complaint, for the FCA, or for the Financial Ombudsman Service — and that is an access-and-retention question, not a reading-everything question.

Can an AR keep using its own WhatsApp number?

It can, provided you have settled the consequences in advance: who controls the WhatsApp Business Account, how you get to the message history, what happens to it when the appointment ends, and how you sample conversations in the meantime. A number the AR controls and you cannot see is the arrangement that fails an annual review.

What changes if the AR is an introducer AR?

The permitted scope is much narrower — broadly, making introductions and distributing certain promotional material — so the monitoring question becomes whether the conversation is staying inside it. A chat that starts as an introduction and drifts into answering questions about cover has left the scope, and the principal carries that.

Do we need a separate WhatsApp number for each AR?

Not necessarily. One brokerage number with named users, per-user access and a clear signature convention gives clients a consistent identity and gives you a single place to sample and retain. Separate numbers per AR make sense where each trades under its own name locally, but then each one needs its own display name approval, its own template set and its own line in the oversight pack.

How long should chat records be kept?

There is no single duration for general insurance business in the Handbook; you keep records for as long as you need them to demonstrate compliance and to defend a complaint, which in practice means aligning retention with the limitation periods and the Ombudsman's time limits rather than with a WhatsApp export button. Set the period, write it into the AR agreement, and make sure the AR cannot delete the thread unilaterally.

See ORIS in action

Shared WhatsApp inbox, client records, follow-ups and opportunities for the whole brokerage. 15-minute demo.

Book a demo

Free kit : WhatsApp template pack for insurance brokers

This guide and its companions as a printable PDF, with a sourced checklist up front. 15 pages · PDF · 601 KB.

See the kit
Book a demo